July 5, 2011

When should Joe Girardi bite the bullet and move Derek Jeter down in the order?

Yes, I have more Derek Jeter commentary from Tyler Kepner’s column I alluded to earlier this morning.

As usual, Kepner penned an excellent piece. He didn’t dance around the tough Jeter lineup question, and he also acknowledged Joe Girardi’s points about keeping him as a leadoff hitter.

“I think people sometimes manage short term,” Girardi said. “When [Brett Gardner] was in the leadoff spot and wasn’t hitting, everyone wanted me to move him out of the leadoff spot.”

As Kepner later mentioned, Jeter isn’t just going through a cold spell; he hasn’t hit like the 3,000-hit Jeter since 2009.


Fans would never exonerate Girardi if he moved Jeter down in the lineup, or even benched him, before he gets the last six hits he needs to reach the major hitting milestone.

The Yankees play two more with the Indians this week before returning home for a four-game series with the Rays to conclude the first half. That means Jeter needs to average a hit per game to reach 3,000 on the nose before the All-Star break. Girardi will hope Jeter hits the milestone quickly if he starts plaguing his suddenly hot team.

After watching the Yankees win 14 of 18 games in Jeter’s absence, I think Girardi is just waiting for a few days after Jeter reaches the milestone before moving him down in the order.

What about you, when do you think Girardi should move Jeter down in the lineup?

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
If I were Girardi, Jeter would be down in the order TODAY. Brett Gardner is a much better lead-off man that Jeter, cause Gardner has it all. He can manufacture his own run, he steals, he has speed, and he's becoming a better bunter. Girardi should stick with Gardner, cause it seems when Jeter leads off, the team seems to lose more.
I agree, put Jeter to #6 or lower. He can still get his at-bats. Last night he looked awfully bad. I saw two 92-MPH fastballs right down the middle and he just couldn't get around on them. Maybe he just needs a few games to get his swing back, but you don't have him do this at the top of the order. And "getting his swing back" means a .260 hitter. #6 or lower. No dishonor, just what's good for the team. It's interesting the Yankees have become so emotional about these things. They used to be all business, like the Sox are today. Nomar slows down, they get rid of him. Same with Manny, Pedro, Boggs, Clemons. I'm not saying the Yankees should get rid of Jeter, Posada, Mo, but let's face it, they have to get phased out oneway or another.
Jeter should be taken out of the leadoff spot when a better option is available. Right now, none is. Brett Gardner doesn't get on base enough. The next-best option is Curtis Granderson, and the way he's hitting, the 2 spot is a much better place for him.

Post a new comment

Comments by

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP